Medical Assistant vs CNA: Best Hire for Small Healthcare Businesses 

A small healthcare business faces unique challenges when building a reliable and efficient team. One of the most common decisions is hiring a Medical Assistant (MA) or a Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA). Both roles are essential in healthcare but offer different skills and carry different responsibilities. Understanding the differences between a medical assistant vs CNA can help you determine the proper role that fits your practice's specific needs.

At Pearl Talent, we specialize in sourcing top-tier remote professionals, including expert Medical Assistants skilled in medical billing, coding, and patient support. We partner with companies in the US and EU to provide reliable, motivated, and cost-effective talent from around the globe, including the Philippines, South Africa, and more. As your trusted talent partner, we help you build an optimized workforce that seamlessly blends US-based and international talent.

Based on our countless successful placements in the healthcare field, we compiled this blog to help small healthcare businesses understand the difference between medical assistant and CNA. We will dissect each role's pros and cons to help you decide which one best aligns with your practice’s needs and goals.

Let's dive in!

What is a Medical Assistant? 

A medical assistant is a healthcare professional who supports doctors and nurses in various administrative and clinical tasks. A CNA, on the other hand, focuses primarily on basic patient care, like feeding and bathing. Understanding the difference between medical assistant vs CNA is essential when hiring for small healthcare businesses.

Key Responsibilities of Medical Assistants

Medical assistants are responsible for various tasks that support the smooth operation of medical facilities. Typically, their main tasks include both administrative and clinical duties. This flexibility allows them to serve as valuable assets, especially in smaller healthcare settings.

• Administrative Duties: Medical assistants are responsible for scheduling appointments, managing billing, and coordinating insurance claims. They also help maintain electronic health records (EHR) to ensure accurate patient data. 
• Clinical Support: MAs take patient vitals, such as blood pressure, temperature, and pulse. They also prepare patients for exams and assist doctors during procedures. 
• Patient Engagement: Medical assistants interact with patients by explaining treatment plans and providing instructions for follow-up care. They educate patients about procedures and answer basic healthcare questions.
• Multi-tasking: MAs are highly versatile as they can handle administrative and clinical responsibilities. They switch seamlessly between tasks, ensuring the office runs smoothly. 
• Versatility for Small Practices: MAs are capable of performing a variety of roles. From front-office tasks to clinical support, they ensure a well-rounded approach to patient care, making them instrumental for small practices with limited manpower.

Understanding the medical assistant vs CNA roles is crucial for making the right hire for your practice. 

When deciding between a medical assistant and a CNA, it may be more advantageous to choose the former if you’re short-staffed on both the clinical and administrative sides. MAs offer flexibility and multi-tasking abilities that are especially beneficial for small healthcare businesses. 

What is a Certified Nursing Assistant?

A Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA) is a healthcare worker who provides direct patient care under the supervision of a registered nurse. The chief advantage of a CNA vs MA lies in their focus on this aspect of clinical duties.

Key Responsibilities of Certified Nursing Assistants

Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs) are essential for hands-on patient care. They support patients who need assistance with daily tasks and essential health monitoring. CNAs work closely with nurses to ensure patients receive proper care and attention. Usually, a CNA's day-to-day duties involve the following:

• Direct Patient Care: CNAs assist patients with daily activities like bathing, dressing, eating, and mobility. They provide physical support to patients who struggle with these tasks.
• Basic Clinical Tasks: CNAs monitor vital signs, such as temperature, blood pressure, and heart rate. CNAs also focus on ensuring patient comfort during their care routines.
• Support for Nurses: CNAs act as a communication link between patients and nurses. They report any health concerns or changes in patient conditions promptly. 
• Patient Mobility Assistance: CNAs help patients move safely, whether transferring from a bed to a wheelchair or walking around. They prevent falls and injuries by providing physical support.
• Emotional Support: CNAs often provide emotional comfort to patients by listening and engaging with them. They help patients feel less isolated during their care. 

CNAs focus more on basic patient care than administrative tasks. They are particularly valuable in settings like long-term care facilities and rehabilitation centers. Choosing between a medical assistant vs CNA can also depend on the level of patient care your practice needs.

Differences in Training and Certification Requirements

Whether a medical assistant or a CNA, each role has different training and certification requirements. Understanding the differences between training for a medical assistant vs CNA is essential for small healthcare businesses. 

Medical Assistants

Medical assistants need specific training to perform both clinical and administrative tasks. Their education prepares them for a variety of roles in healthcare. Training requirements vary depending on state and employer needs. Here's the typical educational path of a Medical Assistant:  

• Educational Programs: Most medical assistants complete a certificate or associate degree program from an accredited school. Depending on the degree, they usually take 1-2 years to complete.  
• Clinical Training: A medical assisting program includes hands-on clinical medical assistant training. Students learn to take vital signs, prepare patients for exams, and assist with minor procedures. 
• Administrative Training: A medical assistant program teaches essential administrative skills like scheduling, managing medical records and medical billing and coding. These skills are critical for handling front-office tasks. 
• Optional Certifications: After completing training, a physician assistant can pursue certifications like the CMA (Certified Medical Assistant). While not always required, certifications can improve job prospects. 
• State Regulations: Some states may have additional requirements for medical assistants, such as specific certifications or continuing education. Employers may also prefer candidates with certifications. 

Medical assistants typically complete more formal training compared to CNAs. Their educational requirements focus on balancing clinical and administrative tasks, making them versatile hires for small practices. Understanding the difference between medical assistant vs CNA training is essential for making the right choice.  

CNAs

Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs) must complete specific training and certification before starting their careers. The training focuses on hands-on patient care and meeting state-mandated standards. CNA roles are highly regulated because they deal directly with vulnerable patients. Here are the key features of CNA training programs:

• Shorter Training Programs: CNA training programs typically last 4-12 weeks, shorter than many other healthcare roles. These programs focus on practical skills like bathing, feeding, and assisting patients with mobility. This quick training timeline makes CNA careers an accessible option for those entering healthcare.  
• State-Mandated Certification: Aspiring CNAs must pass a state certification exam after completing training. The exam includes a written test and a practical skills evaluation. Certification ensures CNAs are prepared for their critical role in direct patient care.  
• Focus on Direct Patient Care: CNA programs emphasize skills for assisting patients with daily activities and health monitoring. This includes learning proper techniques to handle patients safely and respectfully. The curriculum also covers infection control and emergency response basics.  
• Clinical Experience Requirements: Most CNA programs require hands-on clinical hours in a supervised setting. This experience helps students practice real-world caregiving under professional guidance. Clinical training ensures CNAs are ready for their responsibilities from day one.  
• Renewal and Continuing Education: CNA certifications often require renewal every 1-2 years, depending on state regulations. Some states also mandate continuing education for CNAs to stay updated on best practices. These requirements maintain high standards in the profession.  

Training differences are one of the primary factors that decide the pros and cons of medical assistant and CNA roles, especially for small businesses. Since CNAs require less training than medical assistants, they have lower salaries but limited capabilities. MAs, on the other hand, are more versatile but can be more costly. 

The training time of each can also impact their availability, with CNAs potentially being more readily accessible. Their faster pathway from enrolling in a CNA program to entering the workforce can entice more people to become CNAs, increasing the available talent pool in a specific area.

Pros and Cons of Hiring a Medical Assistant vs CNA

Medical assistants and CNAs possess unique strengths and limitations. Given that CNAs are limited to assisting with patient care, they may not be the best choice if you also need help on the administrative side. However, there are certain disadvantages to hiring MAs that may make it worth simply hiring a CNA along with another staffer.

Pros and Cons of Hiring Medical Assistants

The pros and cons of hiring medical assistants are essential to consider for small healthcare businesses. They help you understand how medical assistants can fit into your practice. Below are the advantages of hiring one. 

• Versatile Skill Set: Medical assistants are trained in clinical and administrative tasks. This flexibility allows them to manage front-office duties and assist in patient care, making them highly efficient.
• Time-Saving: With their multitasking ability, medical assistants reduce the need to hire separate staff for clinical and administrative roles. This saves time and resources for small healthcare businesses.  
• Patient Interaction: Medical assistants often engage with patients, helping them understand procedures and care plans. Their communication skills improve patient satisfaction and overall care experience.  

Here are the cons of medical assistants that may affect your hiring decision:  

• Longer Training Time: Medical assistants typically require more extended training programs, ranging from months to two years. This can reduce the number of available MAs you can hire at any given time.
• Higher Salary Expectations: Medical assistants generally earn more than CNAs, which might not suit smaller budgets. This is especially relevant for small healthcare businesses with limited resources.  
• Less Focus on Direct Care: While trained for clinical tasks, medical assistants spend less time on hands-on patient care. This may be better for practices that prioritize direct patient support.  

Hiring medical assistants can be an excellent option for practices needing versatile staff who handle multiple roles. However, their salary requirements and less focus on hands-on care can tilt the balance in the CNA’s favor. 

Pros and Cons of Hiring Certified Nursing Assistants

CNAs offer unique benefits focused on inpatient care. Consider the following advantages of hiring CNAs for your team.   

• Excellent for Hands-On Patient Care: CNAs are highly skilled at providing direct patient care, such as bathing, feeding, and assisting with mobility. They focus on ensuring patient comfort and safety, which is essential in many healthcare settings.  
• Lower Salary Requirements: CNAs typically earn lower wages than other healthcare roles. This can make them a more budget-friendly option for small healthcare businesses.  
• Quicker Training Period: CNA training programs are shorter, often lasting only 4-12 weeks. This allows healthcare businesses to quickly hire and onboard trained staff.  

Watch out for these disadvantages when considering CNAs for your practice:    

• Limited Administrative Capabilities: CNAs focus on patient care and are not typically trained in administrative tasks. This limits their ability to handle office duties like scheduling or billing.  
• Best Suited for Specific Care-Focused Roles: CNAs are best for roles that require direct patient care, such as in hospitals or long-term care facilities. They may not be the best fit for practices requiring a mix of clinical and administrative tasks.  
• Less Versatility: CNAs are highly skilled in patient care but may need to be more adaptable for multitasking across various roles. This can be limited in smaller healthcare businesses with diverse needs.  

While CNAs are ideal for long-term care settings, medical assistants are often better suited for outpatient clinics. However, given the lower 

Key Takeaway

The choice between a medical assistant vs CNA depends on the specific needs of your healthcare practice. While medical assistants are trained in administrative and clinical tasks, making them ideal for multitasking roles, CNAs are specifically trained in providing direct patient care under the supervision of practical nurses.

Therefore, the choice largely hinges on whether you need to manage office work or assist patients more. It can also depend on the size of your team, the type of healthcare services you offer, and the kind of support you need, with MAs often being more capable than CNAs in certain clinical aspects. 

Do you need to hire skilled healthcare support staff for your small practice, such as virtual Medical Assistants or CNAs? Pearl Talent can help you source top-tier professionals from around the world tailored to your needs. With our efficient remote hiring process, we place skilled, reliable, and cost-effective candidates to ensure your practice runs smoothly.

‍